Skip to main content

Why are most RPG openings bad?

 Yesterday, I was talking about the classic Fallout games' openings with a friend of mine, and we both arrived at an uncannily accurate observation: most RPGs in general, no matter the developer or the culture it came from, have terrible, or at best mediocre openings that don't exactly put their best feet forward, compromising either on the gameplay with really long expository or story centric scenes, or on the story with an uninspired early dungeon featuring really weak enemies.

Why is that? Well, I posed the question to a few places, and came across what I think is a comprehensive answer:

1. I credit my friend for bringing this point up, but essentially RPGs find themselves needing to come up with good reasons for their characters to be adventuring the world instead of going on with their regular lives at home, like regular people. This imposes certain narrative limitations, as there's a very limited width of explanations that satisfactorily meet this need, and often RPG story writers find themselves explaining the need for adventure with a contrast between the idyllic past and the uncertain present, which often necessitates a fair bit of exposition.

2. Gameplay wise, RPGs are bound by the need to make players feel like they're progressing their characters, as in, making them stronger as they go through the game. For this purpose, it's necessary to make the gains from levels, weapons, magics etc matter, which is often achieved by making them start weak, as each gain feels substantially stronger when being added to a weak base. However, this also constricts enemy design, forcing them to be weak to give the player a fair chance, as otherwise they would merely be locked in a constant, hopeless loop. The downside of this is that early game enemies have little space to be interesting or deep, often just turning into glorified bags of xp.

There are obviously more nuances to the matter, but I feel this broadly covers the problems with making RPG openings. What do you think? Feel free to share your thoughts!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

About Me

Professional dilettante. Former assembly coding enthusiast, dabbled with writing reviews and analyses, currently training to be a statistician. Notable creations: Circle of the Moon Card Mode romhack Jets of Time, the Chrono Trigger open world randomizer To the Moon minisode 1 tester: "Dev J Chand" is me. Contact: dev221117@gmail.com Discord Bluesky

Final Fantasy 6: All About Losers

 So, as it happens, I managed to reexperience some of Final Fantasy 6 through a Let's Play of its Pixel Remaster. On the whole, the game remains enjoyable and entertaining as an experience, despite some aspects that haven't aged very well. But that made me ponder what I liked about it, and I think I have found a rather simple, if seemingly contrarian answer: Final Fantasy 6 is a story about losers. Think about it. Terra, the very first protagonist we're introduced to, is a vacuous woman who constantly struggles with doubts about herself and her decisions. Locke, well, he constantly has complexes over a girlfriend who died ages ago and whose corpse he constantly preserves in a basement attended to by a creepy guy. Edgar? Sabin? Well, they're definitely a touch more adjusted than most of the protagonists, but are by no means flawless beings, and definitely no selfless paladins in shining armor. Edgar is, as is often noted, a smart and capable ruler who also happens to be ...

Some screenshots from Aria of Sorrow Castle B

 Ever since I played Harmony of Dissonance, I always wondered what a moody and hellish version of Aria of Sorrow's castle would look like, ala Castle B of the former game. JonataGuitar's excellent recolor mod for AoS inspired me to work on this idea. It took quite a lot of practice, and opinions from others, but I'm happy with what I've got so far. Screenshots below: Let me know what you think! As for the next post of A Long Look at To the Moon: it's coming soon. Stay tuned!